Substantive Change: Contractual Arrangements
Prior HLC approval or notification may be required for substantive changes related to the initiation, modification or renewal of contractual arrangements. A contractual arrangement is an arrangement in which the institution outsources some portion of its academic programs—that is, degrees or certificates offered for academic credit—to:
- An unaccredited institution.
- An institution that is not accredited by an accreditor recognized by the U.S. Department of Education.
- A corporation or other entity.
The services provided by the contractual party may include instruction, oversight of the curriculum, assurance of the consistency in the level and quality of instruction and in expectations of student performance, and/or the establishment of the academic qualifications for instructional personnel.
Arrangements That Do Not Require HLC Approval or Notification
HLC approval or notification is not required for arrangements between an institution and a third party in which any of the following conditions apply:
- The contract is solely for goods and services, such as food services and parking lot management, that are unrelated to the provision of academic programs.
- The institution offers the goods or services to another party. (Note that if the other party is an accredited or candidate for accreditation with HLC, that party may need to seek approval for the arrangement.)
- The contractual partner provides an internship that does not include a formal instructional component.
- The contractual partner provides only books or supplies supporting the academic program or only equipment or a platform for internet-based instruction.
- The contract between the contractual partner and the institution provides only for the articulation or transfer of courses that are transcribed as transfer credit on the students’ transcripts and not the outsourcing of courses carrying academic credit from the institution.
In addition, the following arrangements do not fall under the definition of a contractual arrangement and do not require HLC approval or notification:
- Consortial Arrangement: An arrangement in which all of the contractual partners providing goods or services related to academic programs are institutions accredited by agencies recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. As of February 2020, institutions are no longer required to notify HLC of or request prior approval for consortial arrangements.
- Credit Transfer: Based on its transfer policy, an institution independently determines whether credits already earned by a student from another institution are acceptable in transfer. These determinations may be based on credit, course and curriculum equivalencies, often without reference to partial fulfillment of a specific credential. Each institution teaches its own curriculum and courses; there is no outsourcing involved.
An institution may decide whether to accept credits from other institutions regardless of their accredited status. HLC requires member institutions to clearly communicate their transfer policies to the public. - Articulation Agreement: An arrangement between institutions that agree in advance, via Memorandum of Understanding or other agreement, to accept each other’s credits in transfer, often in partial fulfillment of one or more specific credentials. In these cases, students may be simultaneously enrolled in multiple institutions. Each institution teaches its own curriculum and courses; there is no outsourcing involved.
Institutions may decide whether to enter into articulation arrangements with other institutions regardless of the other institution’s accredited status. However, HLC member institutions should make the public aware of all such arrangements (e.g. by listing such arrangements on the website, providing more details in program catalogs and ensuring clarity in the transcript produced as a result of such arrangements).
Screening Form for Contractual Arrangements
Institutions engaging in any arrangement that meets the definition above should complete HLC’s screening form for contractual arrangements.
Note: Institutions that are currently on or recently removed from HLC sanction or Show-Cause Order, or that are under provisional certification, are subject to additional requirements and should complete this alternative screening form.
Types of Requests

The following information is provided for general guidance. Institutions planning a change related to a contractual agreement should contact their HLC staff liaison to confirm that prior HLC approval or notification is required.
Expand All Sections
Note: Expand all sections before printing this page.
HLC Notification Required*
How to Notify HLC
Completion of the screening form constitutes notification.
* Prior HLC approval is required if the institution is in any of the categories listed below. These institutions should complete this alternative screening form, and HLC will provide further instructions.
- The institution is currently on Notice, Probation or under a Show-Cause Order (placed on the sanction or Show-Cause Order after July 1, 2020);
- In the prior three years, the institution has been on Notice, Probation or under a Show-Cause Order (placed on the sanction or Show-Cause Order after July 1, 2020); or
- The institution is currently under a provisional certification status with the U.S. Department of Education, and that status was assigned on or after July 1, 2020.
Prior HLC Approval Required
How to Apply
Complete the screening form and, if required, submit the Contractual Arrangement Application .
Possible Review Processes
Review and Decision-Making Timeline
Within 90 days of receipt of a materially complete application
Note that federal regulations provide that educational programs provided through contractual arrangements between an accredited institution and an ineligible entity wherein more than 50 percent of the educational program is being provided by the ineligible entity will not receive Title IV assistance even if approved by the accreditor.
Prior HLC Approval Required
How to Apply
Complete the screening form and, if required, submit the Contractual Arrangement Application .
Possible Review Processes
Note: This type of contractual arrangement will receive intense scrutiny and will not be approved by HLC except in exceptional circumstances.
Review and Decision-Making Timeline
Within 90 days of receipt of a materially complete application
Questions?
Contact HLC at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Review HLC's Glossary for definitions of terms related to substantive change.